Skip to main content
Corporate Law

AI-Powered Businesses: Legal Considerations in Ontario

Operating an AI-powered business in Ontario raises legal questions across multiple areas: who owns AI-generated intellectual property, who is liable when AI makes a harmful decision, how privacy laws apply to AI training and inference data, where federal AI legislation stands now that the proposed Artificial Intelligence and Data Act (AIDA) has lapsed, and how contracts should address AI-specific risks.

Updated
Contents+

Key Takeaways

  • Canada's proposed Artificial Intelligence and Data Act (AIDA) never became law. It died on the Order Paper with Bill C-27 when Parliament was prorogued on January 6, 2025, and as of October 2026 no federal AI statute has replaced it.
  • Copyright in AI-generated content is uncertain under Canadian law — purely AI-generated works may not qualify for copyright protection under the Copyright Act, potentially leaving them in the public domain.
  • AI businesses must comply with PIPEDA when using personal data for training, inference, or personalization, and its consent and transparency obligations apply fully. The proposed CPPA died with Bill C-27, and the new federal privacy bill (Bill C-36) is not yet law.
  • Liability for AI decisions is currently determined under general tort law, contract, and the Ontario Human Rights Code — automated discrimination is not exempt from the Code.
  • Contracts for AI products and services must address AI-specific risks: output warranty limitations, data ownership, training data rights, indemnification for AI-generated IP claims, and acceptable use restrictions.

Intellectual Property Ownership of AI Output

Who owns content, inventions, or other outputs generated by AI systems is one of the most consequential and unsettled questions in Canadian IP law. See the companion entry on AI Intellectual Property in Canada for a full analysis; this section summarizes the key points for business planning.

Copyright Act — no protection for purely AI-generated works: The Copyright Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. C-42, requires an 'author' who is a human being for copyright to subsist. The Canadian Intellectual Property Office (CIPO) and courts have not extended copyright protection to works generated entirely by AI without meaningful human authorship. The implication for businesses: AI-generated content (text, images, code) may be in the public domain if no human author made sufficient creative choices.

The human-in-the-loop question: If humans provide meaningful creative direction, selection, or arrangement of AI-generated content, the human contribution may attract copyright protection. The line between 'mere prompting' and 'sufficient authorship' is contested and has not been conclusively resolved by Canadian courts.

Contractual assignment: AI businesses should ensure that any IP created using AI tools is addressed in their agreements — with employees (via employment agreements including IP assignment clauses), contractors (via independent contractor agreements), and clients (via explicit terms of service or service agreements specifying who owns the AI outputs).

Competitor IP concerns: Businesses training AI models on third-party data (including scraped web content) should conduct due diligence on whether that training data includes copyright-protected works. Using copyrighted works to train models without a licence may constitute infringement in Canada, though this has not been definitively resolved by Canadian courts.

Liability for AI Decisions

When an AI system makes a decision that causes harm — a medical AI gives an incorrect diagnosis, a lending AI denies a loan based on biased data, an autonomous vehicle causes an accident, a fraud-detection AI flags the wrong account — who is liable?

Current Canadian framework: There is no statute that specifically governs AI liability in Canada. Liability is determined under existing legal frameworks:

Tort law — negligence: For an AI developer or deployer to be liable in negligence, the plaintiff must establish:

  1. A duty of care (the developer/deployer owed a duty to the plaintiff)
  2. Breach of the standard of care (the developer/deployer's conduct fell below what a reasonable person in their position would do)
  3. Causation (the breach caused the harm)
  4. Damages (actual harm resulted)

In Canada, establishing that an AI developer owed a duty of care to the ultimate end user of their product may be straightforward (applying the Anns-Cooper test from the Supreme Court of Canada), but proving what the 'standard of care' is for AI systems is difficult given the absence of statutory standards.

Product liability: AI software embedded in physical products (e.g., an autonomous vehicle, a medical device) may attract product liability principles. In Canada, product liability claims can be brought in negligence or under provincial consumer protection legislation.

Contract law: Between commercial parties, liability for AI decisions is primarily governed by contract. Service agreements should explicitly address AI-specific risks: warranty exclusions for AI outputs, limitation of liability clauses, indemnification for third-party claims, and clear statements about which party is responsible for reviewing and validating AI outputs.

Human Rights Code: AI systems used in employment decisions (hiring algorithms, performance evaluation tools) or in the provision of services must not discriminate on prohibited grounds under the Ontario Human Rights Code, R.S.O. 1990, c. H.19. Automated discrimination is not exempt from the Code merely because it was performed by an algorithm.

Practical liability mitigation: Ontario AI businesses should: document the intended scope and limitations of their AI systems; maintain audit trails of AI decisions; include contractual disclaimers and limitations of liability in their terms of service; carry appropriate professional liability or errors and omissions insurance; and implement human oversight for high-stakes AI decisions.

Privacy Law and AI: PIPEDA and Ontario Considerations

Privacy law is one of the most active areas of AI regulation. Ontario AI businesses that collect, use, or disclose personal information in connection with AI training, inference, or output are subject to privacy obligations under multiple statutes.

PIPEDA: The Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act, S.C. 2000, c. 5 (PIPEDA), governs the collection, use, and disclosure of personal information in the course of commercial activities. Key PIPEDA obligations for AI businesses:

Consent: You must generally obtain meaningful consent before collecting personal information for AI training or use. Using personal data scraped from the web to train AI models without consent is likely a PIPEDA violation.

Purpose limitation: Personal information collected for one purpose (e.g., a customer's purchase history) generally cannot be used for a materially different purpose (e.g., training a marketing AI) without fresh consent.

Safeguards: Businesses must implement security safeguards appropriate to the sensitivity of personal information. AI training datasets containing sensitive personal information require strong data security controls.

Transparency: PIPEDA's openness principle requires organizations to be transparent about their personal information handling practices, including AI-related uses. Privacy policies must accurately describe any AI processing of personal data.

Ontario's PHIPA: The Personal Health Information Protection Act, 2004, S.O. 2004, c. 3, Sched. A (PHIPA), imposes stricter obligations on AI systems in the Ontario healthcare context. Health AI systems must comply with PHIPA's consent, purpose limitation, and safeguard requirements, and may require a Privacy Impact Assessment.

Proposed Consumer Privacy Protection Act (CPPA): Bill C-27 also included the Consumer Privacy Protection Act (CPPA), which would have replaced the private sector privacy rules in Part 1 of PIPEDA and would have given individuals a right to an explanation of automated decisions that could have a significant impact on them. The CPPA died with Bill C-27 and is not law, so PIPEDA still applies. In June 2026, the federal government introduced a new privacy bill, Bill C-36, which would enact the Protecting Privacy and Consumer Data Act and repeal Part 1 of PIPEDA. As introduced, it would require an organization that used an automated decision system to make a prediction, recommendation or decision that could have a legal or similarly significant effect on an individual to explain it on request. As of October 2026, Bill C-36 has only had first reading in the House of Commons and may change before it passes, if it passes at all. Ontario AI businesses can design with these proposals in mind, but PIPEDA's current rules are the ones that apply.

Contractual Considerations for AI Businesses

For Ontario AI businesses — whether selling AI software products, providing AI services, or licensing AI models — contracts must address a set of AI-specific risk allocations that standard software agreements do not adequately cover.

Key contractual provisions for AI businesses:

Output warranty limitations: AI outputs are probabilistic and can be incorrect. Contracts should clearly disclaim warranties of accuracy, completeness, or fitness for purpose of AI outputs, and specify that the client is responsible for validating outputs before acting on them.

Acceptable use policies: Define what the client can and cannot use the AI for. Prohibit uses that are illegal, that could generate discriminatory outputs, or that violate third-party IP rights.

Data ownership and training: Address who owns any data the client provides, whether the provider can use that data to train or improve the AI model, and what data is retained after the contract ends. Many enterprise clients will reject provisions allowing their data to be used for model training.

Indemnification: Who indemnifies whom if the AI generates content that infringes a third party's IP, defames someone, or causes regulatory harm? This is a heavily negotiated point.

Audit rights: Enterprise clients increasingly require the right to audit AI systems for bias, accuracy, and compliance with agreed standards.

AI regulatory compliance: AIDA did not become law, but contracts should still say which party is responsible for complying with AI-specific rules that apply now, such as sector regulation, and with any federal AI legislation that is enacted later.

The Bottom Line

Operating an AI business in Ontario requires navigating a complex and evolving legal landscape. Existing laws — privacy, IP, tort, human rights, consumer protection — apply to AI in ways that are still being tested in courts and regulators. The proposed federal AI statute (AIDA) died with Bill C-27 in January 2025, and as of October 2026 no federal AI statute has replaced it.

Ontario AI businesses should build legal compliance into their product design from the outset (privacy by design, bias mitigation, audit trails), use contracts that clearly allocate AI-specific risks, monitor regulatory developments closely, and seek legal advice before launching products in regulated sectors or where AI decisions significantly affect individuals.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is AIDA and when will it apply to my business?+

AIDA (the Artificial Intelligence and Data Act) was proposed federal legislation included in Bill C-27, aimed at 'high-impact' AI systems. It does not apply to your business because it never became law: Bill C-27 died on the Order Paper when Parliament was prorogued on January 6, 2025. As of October 2026, no federal AI statute has been enacted to replace it. Your AI products are still governed by existing laws, including PIPEDA, the Copyright Act, the Ontario Human Rights Code and consumer protection law. You can track new federal bills on LEGISinfo, the Parliament of Canada's bill tracker.

Can I use publicly available data to train my AI model?+

Not necessarily without legal risk. Using personal data (data about identifiable individuals) from public sources to train AI models may violate PIPEDA's consent requirement. Using copyright-protected works to train AI without a licence may constitute infringement. Conduct a data audit before training to assess the sources and rights in your training data.

Who is liable if my AI system makes a harmful decision?+

Liability depends on the specific circumstances. The developer of the AI system, the business deploying it, and the end user may all potentially bear liability under negligence, contract, or product liability principles. Contracts with clients should clearly allocate responsibility for validating AI outputs and limit the provider's liability for consequential damages.

Can an AI hiring tool violate the Ontario Human Rights Code?+

Yes. The Ontario Human Rights Code prohibits discrimination in employment based on protected grounds (race, gender, age, disability, etc.) regardless of whether the discrimination is carried out by a human or an algorithm. If an AI hiring tool produces discriminatorily disparate outcomes on a protected ground, the employer using it may be liable under the Code.

Do I need to tell customers my service uses AI?+

There is no general Ontario law requiring disclosure that a product or service uses AI. However, privacy law requires transparency about how personal data is used (including in AI systems), and consumer protection law prohibits misleading representations. The proposed CPPA, which would have given individuals a right to an explanation of automated decisions that could significantly affect them, died with Bill C-27. Bill C-36, introduced in June 2026, contains a similar explanation right, but it is not yet law.

Incorporating or restructuring?

Provincial or federal setup, share structure, holding companies and professional corporations. Flat fees, with scope confirmed before any work starts.

Free initial consultation. A lawyer replies within one business day.

Your details and situation
Briefly describe your situation (20 characters minimum).

Prefer to talk? (437) 447-5599 · Mon–Fri, 9 AM – 6 PM

Written by Gagan Lamba, JD — Founder, Lamba Law