Skip to main content
Corporate Law

Non-Compete Agreement

A non-compete agreement (or non-competition covenant) is a contractual restriction preventing a party — typically a departing employee, a selling business owner, or a former shareholder — from competing with a business in a defined geographic area for a defined period of time following the end of their relationship.

Updated
Contents+

Key Takeaways

  • Non-compete covenants in employment contracts are generally void and unenforceable in Ontario for most employees since Bill 27 came into force in October 2021.
  • Non-compete covenants in business sale agreements remain enforceable under the common law reasonableness test.
  • Non-solicitation covenants are narrower than non-competition covenants and remain enforceable in employment contexts if they are reasonable.
  • Ontario courts will not generally rewrite an unreasonably broad non-compete — they will strike it down entirely rather than modify it.
  • Non-competes in shareholder agreements are usually tested under the common law reasonableness test, but if the shareholder is also a non-executive employee, a non-compete the corporation enters into with them can be void under section 67.2 of the ESA.

Employment Non-Competes vs. Business Sale Non-Competes

Ontario law applies very different standards to non-compete agreements depending on the context. Since October 25, 2021, amendments to the Ontario Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA) introduced by Bill 27 (Working for Workers Act, 2021) have made non-competition agreements in employment contracts void and unenforceable for most employees — except for certain high-level executives. This is a significant change from the pre-2021 common law regime. The ESA prohibition only covers agreements between an employer and an employee, and section 67.2 of the ESA has two exceptions. The first is for executives, meaning employees who hold a chief executive position such as CEO, president, CFO or COO. The second is for the sale of a business where, as part of the sale, the seller agrees not to compete with the buyer and becomes the buyer's employee immediately after the sale. Ontario's guide to the ESA limits this sale exception to businesses run as a sole proprietorship or partnership. When a business owner sells their business, agrees not to compete and does not go on to work for the business or the buyer as an employee, the ESA does not apply and the courts use the traditional common law reasonableness test. The ESA can still reach a shareholder who is also an employee: a non-compete that the corporation enters into with a non-executive employee, including one in a shareholder agreement the corporation signs, can be void.

The Common Law Test for Business Sale Non-Competes

Under the common law test, which applies in the context of a business sale or a shareholder agreement, a non-compete covenant will be enforced by Ontario courts if it is reasonable in three dimensions: (1) geographic scope — limited to the area where the business actually operated and where the restriction is needed to protect the purchaser's investment; (2) duration — no longer than reasonably necessary to protect the legitimate business interest; typically 2–5 years for a business sale, potentially longer for a unique or specialized business; and (3) activity restriction — the prohibited activities must be reasonably tied to the business sold and not so broad as to prevent the seller from earning a living in their field. Courts give greater latitude to non-competes in business sale contexts than in employment contexts, because the parties are presumed to be bargaining at arm's length with experienced advisors.

Non-Solicitation vs. Non-Competition

A non-solicitation covenant is narrower than a non-competition covenant — it prevents a departing party from actively soliciting the customers, suppliers, or employees of the former employer or business, but does not prevent them from working in the same industry. In employment contexts, where full non-compete covenants are now void under the ESA for most employees, non-solicitation covenants remain enforceable if they are reasonable in scope and duration. Courts often view non-solicitation covenants as less oppressive because they restrict specific conduct (active solicitation) rather than general participation in an industry. However, a non-solicitation covenant that is effectively equivalent to a non-competition covenant may be recharacterized and struck down.

Severability and the Blue-Pencil Rule

If a court finds that a non-compete agreement is unreasonably broad, it will generally not rewrite the covenant to make it reasonable — Ontario courts prefer to sever the offending portion entirely rather than modify it. The courts have applied the 'blue-pencil' rule in some cases, deleting words that make the covenant too broad if the remaining words make grammatical and commercial sense. However, 'notional severance' — where the court would have to rewrite the covenant to make it reasonable — is generally not available in Ontario. The safer approach is to draft narrow, defensible covenants in the first place rather than drafting broadly and hoping the courts will moderate the excess.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can my employer include a non-compete clause in my Ontario employment contract?+

For most Ontario employees, no — non-competition clauses in employment agreements are void and unenforceable under the ESA since October 2021. The ESA has two exceptions. The first is for executives who hold a chief executive position, such as CEO, president, CFO or COO. The second is for the sale of a business where the seller agrees not to compete and becomes the buyer's employee immediately after the sale, which Ontario's guide to the ESA limits to businesses run as a sole proprietorship or partnership. The ESA prohibition also does not apply to non-competes entered into before October 25, 2021, but those must still meet the common law reasonableness test. Non-solicitation clauses, which are narrower, can still be included and enforced if they are reasonable in scope and duration.

I sold my business and signed a non-compete. How long is it enforceable?+

A non-compete in a business sale agreement is enforceable under the common law reasonableness test. Duration of 2–5 years is common for small to mid-size business sales. For a distinctive or specialized business with strong customer loyalty, courts have upheld longer periods. The specific facts of your business, the industry, and the geographic market all matter to the analysis.

What remedies are available if someone breaches a non-compete?+

A business that suffers a breach of a non-compete can seek an injunction (a court order requiring the competing activity to stop), damages for lost profits caused by the breach, and in some cases an accounting of the profits earned by the breaching party. Injunctions are emergency remedies — if you suspect a breach, legal counsel should be contacted immediately, as delay can undermine the case for an interlocutory injunction.

Need a contract drafted or reviewed?

Commercial agreements, leases, licences and terms of service, reviewed within days with a plain-English note on what to change.

Free initial consultation. A lawyer replies within one business day.

Your details and situation
Briefly describe your situation (20 characters minimum).

Prefer to talk? (437) 447-5599 · Mon–Fri, 9 AM – 6 PM

Free independent contractor agreement

Written by Gagan Lamba, JD — Founder, Lamba Law